skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

We had a surprise party for my wife’s 40th birthday. It was FLAWLESS!! Mike the owner was so accommodating with everything. The food was delicious. The Cordon Blue, OMG.... out of this world. The staff was courteous and friendly. The atmosphere was warm and inviting. There is nothing negative that I could say about this place at all.
Hugo Hugasian via google.com - Nov 13, 2020
Food was good , didn't like that was not menu's for the drinks and the bar attended was touching money when he's making drinks,putting garnish on the drinks.
Rossa Roca via google.com - Oct 30, 2020
Every time i eat here the food is sooooo good! Very good service, great menu and very clean atmosphere.
samantha paitakis via google.com - Oct 23, 2020
What a great visit. The food was excellent. The service personable and professional. I highly recommend bistro 25!!
John Hannon via google.com - Oct 11, 2020
Came here for a small wedding dinner. The food is delicious and creative. The service is fantastic!
Lulu Unger via google.com - Oct 10, 2020
Food and service impressive. A must go to restaurant. Owner makes sure you have an enjoyable safe evening.
Rick Schneider via google.com - Oct 10, 2020
We have eaten here several times and the food is always exceptional! I love the arugula and parmigiana cheese salad. I usually order the fish of the day which never disappoints but this time I ordered the short ribs and it was delicious. I would highly recommend Bistro25!
Jandjciulla via google.com - Sep 21, 2020
Try the fish and chips! It's a special on the menu. Outstanding! Ask for extra tartar sauce and malt vinegar because your going to need it.
Mr. Thomas Maslar via google.com - Sep 19, 2020
Great Service! Great food!
john siderius via google.com - Sep 12, 2020
Great food! Great gluten free options!
Catherine LaFalce via google.com - Sep 9, 2020
I enjoyed the corn soup and the short ribs. Just a little bit too much salt. The waitress was attentive and hospitable. I was very happy to witness the manager/owner enforce the MASK regulation. If they were not wearing a mask they had to leave. I would certainly return again.
Selma Jackson via google.com - Aug 29, 2020
Disappointing
We were recommended by a friend to try Bistro 25. We have 5:45 reservations. We were seated outside. My friend is allergic to bees. Once we ordered our drinks the yellow jackets were swarming around us. We asked Gia, our server, if they had any...More ... read more
MonicaK614 via tripadvisor.com - Aug 23, 2020
This place is not overhyped. It's so worth the wait. My group of 5 waited about 40 mins on saturday around lunch time. Not bad at all for a weekend. It's basically a chinese family style restaurant so the portion is big. We ordered the famous chicken wings. They offer bone in and boneless. We got both and I preferred the bone in. T ... read more
Wilbert Hubbard via google.com - Aug 14, 2020
Very good food at reasonable prices. The menu was a little limited probably due to the CoVid virus situation. Staff & service were very friendly & nice. The atmosphere was cozy ... read more
Lee Hecker via google.com - Aug 7, 2020
Had dinner there last Saturday, with my wife. I had the short ribs, dinner was awesome!!!!! Mike the owner is hands on!
steve b via google.com - Aug 6, 2020
(Translated by Google) We had a meal here on our way home from Fire Island. We were in rush because of the train schedule, but the serving was quick and the waitress was very kind. Of course the meals tasted amazing! And the owner kindly offered us to drive us to the station so we can relax and get more time to enjoy the meal!! I mea ... read more
Yuto N via google.com - Jul 13, 2020
Excellent ... read more
Russell Brooks via google.com - Jul 12, 2020
We had a meal here on our way home from Fire Island. We were in rush because of the train schedule, but the serving was quick and the waitress was very kind. Of course the meals tasted amazing! And the owner kindly offered us to drive us to the station so we can relax and get more time to enjoy the meal!! I mean... what can be better ... read more
Yuto N via google.com - Jul 12, 2020
Had a excellent experience in this spot with my son. The food arrived quickly and the service is just awesome. Prices are reasonable.
R Reed via google.com - Jun 25, 2020
The food is always amazing here, one of my absolute favorites!
Jennifer F. via google.com - Jun 22, 2020
The food was great higley recommended ... read more
TgS BlaDe07 via google.com - Jun 20, 2020
Would surely recommend trying this place. Great character, delicious food, great customer service. Fantastic work.
Gunnar Norman via google.com - Jun 13, 2020
I love this place! I have never been disappointed here. Their fish specials are always so delicious
I love this place! I have never been disappointed here. Their fish specials are always so delicious that I don’t even look at the menu anymore! My husband says all of their meats are all “fall off the bone” good. It’s always our first choice for dinner out.
Elizabeth Rose-Gould via facebook.com - Mar 28, 2020
Did curb side dinner tonight it was EXCELLENT! Thank you ❤️
Did curb side dinner tonight it was EXCELLENT! Thank you ❤️ ... read more
Patricia Keibel Carney via facebook.com - Mar 25, 2020
Food was excellent happy to get take out ... read more
Peter Sheehan via google.com - Mar 19, 2020
Their Brunch. I love the service. And the atmosphere is very quite
Their Brunch. I love the service. And the atmosphere is very quite ... read more
Nicole Aikens via facebook.com - Mar 9, 2020
Dinner with friends
Wonderful atmosphere, very warm and comfortable-don't be deterred by the lack of curb appeal (cant always judge a book by its cover) when inside you'll be pleasantly surprised. The menu has a lot of variety with a bar menu that can be ordered at the...More ... read more
dmulvaney via tripadvisor.com - Mar 5, 2020
We love this place.
dennis dandrea via google.com - Feb 28, 2020
Mac and cheese with lobster is off the hook!
Les Spence via google.com - Feb 16, 2020
Great food. nice staff. good drinks ... read more
Ronald Curaba via google.com - Feb 15, 2020
great service from everyone especially Jack. yummmmmmy risotto.
great service from everyone especially Jack. yummmmmmy risotto.
Karen Vano via facebook.com - Feb 9, 2020
Great food, atmosphere and service! Love the chicken and lemongrass dumplings! Yummy! I highly recommend you visit this low key and quaint restuarant.
Susan Camuso via google.com - Jan 30, 2020
Really good food During restaurant week. Kinda dark pulling up and thought it was closed at first. The shrimp was nice and light. The beek to me needed some salt. But hey that's what asking for salt is for 🤷🏾‍♂️ ... read more
Eugen Martin via google.com - Jan 30, 2020
Very nice place with exceptional food & service. A bit pricey so it may not be a weekly event. Will definitely return when back in town.
Angela Osullivan via google.com - Jan 27, 2020
Can’t go wrong
Nice atmosphere, great food and good service. We go 2 or 3 times a month. You can’t go wrong. Enjoy!!
scooter160 via tripadvisor.com - Jan 20, 2020
Very good food and service was good ... read more
Claire Guy via google.com - Jan 14, 2020
Very good food and service ... read more
Claire Guy via google.com - Jan 11, 2020
Dinner out with friends and food and staff were amazing! Our waiter Chris was wonderful. Thanks for a delicious meal and a wonderful evening out with friends.
kathy russell via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
Great place for lunch!
Stopped in on a Saturday afternoon with a friend for lunch. We were seated right away and shortly after most tables were taken. Our friendly waiter explained all the specials. I started with the Manhattan clam chowder which was very good but could have used...More ... read more
pageporter via tripadvisor.com - Dec 22, 2019
Fantastic as always great food great service ... read more
D Pamlanye via google.com - Dec 21, 2019
Excellent dishes.... professional and courteous service.. may have to make it a weekly date for brunch with my husband.
Kathy Patterson via google.com - Dec 15, 2019
Wonderful dinning experience. Food was amazing and staff was spot on. Five 🌟
Wonderful dinning experience. Food was amazing and staff was spot on. Five 🌟 ... read more
Patricia Berger via facebook.com - Dec 14, 2019
Seasonal brunch, lunch & dinner menu, moderately priced, delicious menu choices. Soup of the day +
Seasonal brunch, lunch & dinner menu, moderately priced, delicious menu choices. Soup of the day + the best French onion soup. Excellent breakfast potatoes, chicken pot pie, braised short ribs, steak sandwich, crab cakes, homemade desserts w/fresh whip cream!
Julia Abreu via facebook.com - Nov 24, 2019
Surprised in Sayville
lovely meal for two on a busy saturday night. owner/host was charming. appetizer (rock shrimp) delicious and they thoughtfully split the arugula salad. crab cakes (main course) were very good (almost all crab no breadcrumbs or filler) but not super flavorful.
mtktaveler via tripadvisor.com - Nov 18, 2019
the owner is a great person
the owner is a great person ... read more
Imtou Hyppolite via facebook.com - Nov 11, 2019
Love the service, the food, and the Mike the Mgr. is the best.
Love the service, the food, and the Mike the Mgr. is the best.
Florence Spataro via facebook.com - Nov 8, 2019
Great brunch, nice atmosphere ... read more
Glenn Siemsen via google.com - Oct 25, 2019
First time here last night with a party of 8. I had the burrata to start and a cod special that was
First time here last night with a party of 8. I had the burrata to start and a cod special that was out of this world! Others in our party really enjoyed the crab cakes and buttermilk fried chicken. The server, Tyra was excellent! She was friendly, attentive and knowledgeable of the menu! We thoroughly enjoyed this dining experience ... read more
Christine Clark via facebook.com - Oct 23, 2019
My husband and I came last night for our Anniversary. We have been here before. I just had to comme
My husband and I came last night for our Anniversary. We have been here before. I just had to comment about last nights dinners. My husband had the scallops which were perfect. They were paired with a mushroom risotto that was the most delicious risotto I’ve ever tasted. I had the salmon. It literally melted in your mouth. It was pai ... read more
Peggy Travoglino-Karshick via facebook.com - Oct 2, 2019
Great service ... read more
Dennis Leo via google.com - Sep 27, 2019
Decadent menu several items weve never had before. Love that!
MAEDER Landscape & Snow, Ltd. via google.com - Sep 8, 2019
Great choice for a great back to school meal. Oh wait I am retired from school, lol. Really was a great dinner; from the oysters and salads to the main course. All the staff was very friendly and attentive. You definitely should stop by.
Tom Aird via google.com - Sep 4, 2019
great food, a little pricey but not terribly expensive,Very good service* ... read more
Al Bque via google.com - Sep 4, 2019
Delicious food and great atmosphere
There was a group of us, and everyone was delighted with their order! We ALL plan to return sometime soon!
Safari616288 via tripadvisor.com - Sep 3, 2019
Different and delicious menu options.. ate out front on the patio.. thoroughly enjoyed the food and the service..
Laura Dawson via google.com - Aug 29, 2019
Different and delicious menu options.. ate out front on the patio.. thoroughly enjoy the food and the service..
Laura Dawson via google.com - Aug 28, 2019
Amazing food! Terrific service! My new favorite restaurant! My wife had the skirt steak. I had the Sesame Tuna. Both were awesome. I will be coming here every week!
Ritzy Nap via google.com - Aug 25, 2019
No tables available on Saturday at 7:30 although the back room seemed completely empty. Wound up eating at the bar. My glass of wine was $8.00 (reasonably priced) ordered an appetizer of wings, a small said and a chicken burger to share. The order took forever. And appetizer came after we were served the main course. Food was good b ... read more
Liz Lawther via google.com - Aug 23, 2019
My burger was a bit dry and tasteless.
Bear via google.com - Aug 18, 2019
Went with a big party for a rehearsal dinner and staff wasnt very friendly. We asked for the AC to be turned up and management said something along the lines of "its 95 degrees and humid outside, the AC is set to __ and this is as cool as we get." Served shelf tequila when asked for Patron.. not impressed at all. However, food was ta ... read more
samantha stemm via google.com - Aug 16, 2019
Very cute ... read more
Christopher Gee via google.com - Aug 11, 2019
A special find !
This was our first visit by chance after a hike at a nearby park. We feel like we found a jem! The staff was so professional and friendly. Everything was outstanding from the appetizers through to the entree. My husband and son said the oysters...More ... read more
mets3 via tripadvisor.com - Aug 10, 2019
Tasty Brunch
Stopped in on a whim, during the Sayville SummerFest street fair. Was looking for some good food, since the fair was lacking in options. Remembered Bistro 25, which had always been consistently good, so walked over from Main Street. They had just opened, so the...More ... read more
PattyLongIsland via tripadvisor.com - Aug 10, 2019
Exceptional food and service. The entire crew was so generous and accommodating to our family and our needs. I recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants a high quality experience in a beautiful setting.
Joe Rappa via google.com - Aug 6, 2019
We have been to the Bistro a couple of time and I always order the short ribs! They are delicious- very tender and I have ordered this meal every time! Nice atmosphere and the service is good too!
Lee via google.com - Jul 26, 2019
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire